2005 Association of Towns Convention

BACK

 

As Previously Reported By TownOfEvans.com,
The 2005 Association of Towns Convention Was VERY Costly To Evans Taxpayers.
Click Here! To Read Bob Doering's Letter Printed In The Angola Penny Saver.
Click Here! To Read Bob Doering's Letter Printed In The The Sun News.


Download Doering's Letter To The NYS State Comptroller In PDF Format!

Click Here! To Read Bob Doering's Letter To The NYS Comptroller

Download The Draft Petition To NYS Comptroller Alan Hevesi (PDF) - Click Here!
To Print The Draft Petition From Your Browser - Click Here!


At The 3-15-2006 Town Board Meeting, Bob Doering Ask The Town Board If The Person That Purchased The Cheesecake Would Raise Their Hand. Attendees Of The 2005 Association Of Towns Convention Declined To Identify The Person That Purchased The Cheesecake!
 
Should The Person That Purchased This Cheesecake Reimburse Taxpayers?
 
 
 

 
 
All Of The Supervisor's Receipts Were Added Up On A Calculator Tape And Submitted With The His Voucher. On The Left Is A Partial Image Of The Calculator Tape.

Click Here To View Entire Calculator Tape!

 Notice The Total On The Tape Matches The Total On The Voucher.

 The $307.60 In The RED BOX Is The Amount Submitted For The Infamous Lobster Dinners At Taxpayer Expense Meal.

 

 

Notice The $307.60 Matches The Amount On The Calculator Tape.
In Addition To The Questionable Ethics Involved In Having Lobster Dinners At Taxpayer Expense, The Photocopy Of The Receipt For This Meal Raises Many Questions. The Numbers On The Receipt Were Plugged Into A Spreadsheet And The Math DOES NOT ADD UP!
  1. Why Does The Receipt List 12 Meals When The Expense Voucher Is For 6 Attendees? (See Numbers With Purple Background)
  2. If You Add Up The Amounts For The 12 Meals Listed On The Receipt, The Total Is $232.05 Not The $307.60 Submitted For Reimbursement By Supervisor Catalino. $75.55 In Food Expenses Are Unaccounted For On The Photocopy Of The Receipt Provided. Tips, Liquor And Sales Tax Are Not Reimbursable Expenses. Was This $75.55 Food Expense For Meals For Friends & Family That Went To New Your City?
  3. How Was The Unitemized $75.55 Spent?
    1. It's Clear That At Least 12 Meals Were Purchased. Why Wasn't A Detailed Report Submitted Listing The Names Of The 12 People Getting Dinners At Taxpayer Expense?
    2. Will The Supervisor Release A Report Detailing Improper Spending At The Convention?

TOWN CODE IS SITED IN THE SECTION BELOW.
IT APPLIES TO ALL CONVENTION ATTENDEES IN THE TOWN OF EVANS
Town Code Article 48-6 Section D States: Reimbursement will not be made for sales taxes paid, since the town is not required to pay state sales tax (in New York State only). Exemption forms may be obtained from the Town Accountant's office. [Amended 12-15-1993 by L.L. No. 13-1993] EN
WHY ARE TOWN OF EVANS ATTENDEES BEING REIMBURSED FOR SALES TAX WHEN TOWN CODE CLEARLY STATES THAT SALES TAX IS NOT A REIMBURSABLE EXPENSE?
1

2

3

Deputy Supervisor Karen Erickson Submitted An Expense Voucher (1)  For Five (5) Nights At The Sheraton Hotel (2). She Reimbursed The Town For One Night By A Personal Check For $224.00 Even Though She Arrived Two Days Early And The Room Charge Was $244.00! Taxpayers Picked Up The Tab For Erickson's Second Night In NYC Even Though Check In For The Convention Was 4:00 PM The Next Day!

Town Code Article 48-8 Section B States: All airline tickets will be purchased personally in advance of the trip. For reimbursement, a copy of the plane ticket must accompany the travel expense voucher.

Should The Town of Evans Require Each Attendee To Pay For All Their Own Expenses Then Be Reimbursed After The Convention? Separate Receipts For Each Meal? Should Receipts For Shared Items Like Taxi Service Be Divided By The Number Of People In The Taxi And Each Attendee/Person Submit A Prorated Amount? Click Here To Read Town Code (Law) On Travel Expense!

1

2

3

Court Clerk Nancy O'Boyle Drove To NYC.
Her Expense Report (1) Lists 1,000 Miles At 30 A Mile.
Town Code Article 48-5 Section B States: Claims for reimbursement for mileage for general daily travel must be supported by a daily mileage sheet.
She Also Lists $46.01 For Gas (2)
She Also Submitted A Receipt For The Metropolitan Museum (3).
Was She On Town Related Business?
(Click Here To Read IRS Guidelines (Page 9))

.04 Flat rate or stated schedule. A mileage allowance is paid at a flat rate or stated schedule if it is provided on a uniform and objective basis with respect to the expenses described in section 4.03 of this revenue procedure. The allowance may be paid periodically at a fixed rate, at a cents-per-mile rate, at a variable rate based on a stated schedule, at a rate that combines any of these rates, or on any other basis that is consistently applied and in accordance with reasonable business practice. Thus, for example, a periodic payment at a fixed rate to cover the fixed costs (including depreciation (or lease payments), insurance, registration and license fees, and personal property taxes) of driving an automobile in connection with the performance of services as an employee of the employer, coupled with a periodic payment at a cents-per-mile rate to cover the operating costs (including gasoline and all taxes thereon, oil, tires, and routine maintenance and repairs) of using an automobile for those purposes, is an allowance paid at a flat rate or stated schedule. Likewise, a periodic payment at a 9 variable rate based on a stated schedule for different locales to cover the costs of driving an automobile in connection with the performance of services as an employee is an allowance paid at a flat rate or stated schedule.

Supervisor Catalino's / Karen Martin's
Hotel Reservation
Who Is Karen Martin?
Did Evans Taxpayers Pay For Her Hotel?
Why Was The Supervisor Reimbursed For A Double Room And Not A Single Room?
Why Didn't Evans Attendees Stay At The
Less Expensive Milford Hotel?

Click Here! To View Document!
When Did The Town Board Authorize A Reimbursement Check Paid To Karen Martin?

Authorization Does Not Appear In The Minutes!

Click Here! To View Document!

Kathleen Karyczak's
(The Supervisor's Secretary)

Did Evans Taxpayers Pay For The
Supervisor's Secretary AND HER HUSBAND's
Trip To New York City?

2005 Association of Towns Reimbursement Voucher

Click Here! To View Document!

The Supervisor and Other Attendees Submitted Food Vouchers For 5 Days For A 3 Day Convention.

The 2 Town Justices Didn't Submit Food Vouchers For Extra Days.
Is Improper Activity Why They Stayed In A Different Hotel?

Look At This Voucher And See If You Think Our $70,000 A Year Director of Finance Should Have Declined To Pay This Voucher Until It Was Completed Properly According To IRS Guidelines!

Click Here! To View Document!

Supervisor Catalino Submitted A Lunch Receipt That Lists 5 Lunches & 27 Drinks At The Inside Track (Click Here!), A Restaurant With Off Track Betting And A High Rollers Room With A $100 Minimum.
How Many Seminars Did They Attend That Day?
Doesn't It Look Like Drinking Had A Higher Priority Than Attending Seminars?

Click Here! To View Document!
Tom Csati Arrived In NYS At 10:05 AM On 2-19-2005
Click Here! To View Document!
Why Did Tom Csati Submitt A Receipt For $11.30 Which Was One Day Before He Arrived In NYC & 2 Days Before The Convention Check-In?

Where Did This Receipt Come From?
Click Here! To View Document!

Convention Check In Was On 2-20-2005.
Tom Csati Submitted A Receipt For $21.00 For A 7 Day Subway Pass Dated 2-19-2005, The Day Before The Convention Started.
Why Did Tom Csati Need A 7 Day Pass If He Was Busy Attending To The Town's Business At The Convention?
Did Taxpayers Pay For A Subway Pass For Tom Csati's Wife?

Click Here! To View Document!
 
 
HOME GO BACK
 

NOTE: Documents Displayed On This Page Were Obtained Under The Freedom of Information Law

Click Here To Read Town Code (Law) On Travel Expense!.

 
 
 
 
LINKS TO STATE COMPTROLLER ALAN HEVESI'S WEB SITE
 
 

East Meadow Schools Audit Finds Inappropriate Spending, Lax Controls - Click Here!

Comptrollers Investigation Details Extensive Wrongdoing Of Schroeppel Highway Superintendent - Click Here!


 
Download The Petition To NYS Comptroller Alan Hevesi (PDF) - Click Here!
To Print The Petition From Your Browser - Click Here!
 

BACK